Pies & Coffee Cakes

  • Our bakery offers a variety of fresh baked pies & coffee cakes available for purchase daily while supplies last.
  • Because our pies & coffee cakes are baked fresh daily, quantities vary from day to day, so we recommend that customers who wish to purchase a particular kind of pie or coffee cake for a special celebration place an order for the desired pie and/or coffee cake at least 1 day in advance to guarantee your order is ready upon pickup.
  • To place an order for a specific type of pie or cake for your special occasion, either stop in the bakery or contact us by phone at (860) 793-9167.

Pie Menu

  • Pecan Pie
  • Ricotta Pie
  • Pumpkin Pie
  • Lemon Meringue Pie
  • Coconut Custard Pie
  • Apple, Blueberry, & Cherry Lattice Pie
  • Traditional Fruit Filled Pie 
  • Dutch Apple Pie
  • Banana Cream Pie
  • Chocolate Cream Pie

Coffee Cake Menu

  • Blueberry
  • Cherry
  • Apple-Cinnamon
  • Cinnamon Crumb
  • Lemon
  • Banana-Walnut

Specialty Cakes

  • We offer a wide range of freshly baked cakes that are made-to-order for your special occasion, such as a birthday, First Communion, Holy Confirmation, graduation, wedding, or anniversary. 
  • When placing your order, please keep in mind that all of our cakes are double-layered (measuring approx. 4 ½ inches tall).
  • Our cakes are generally decorated in the traditional Italian bakery style; however, we are happy to accommodate our customer’s requests.
  • Pricing varies depending on both the size & type of cake ordered. 
  • Because our specialty cakes are made-to-order, we ask that orders be placed or cancelled at least 24 hours in advance by either stopping in the bakery or by contacting us by phone at (860) 793-9167.

Plain Cake Choices:

  • Chocolate
  • Vanilla
  • Marble

Frosting/Icing Choices:

  • Butter Cream
  • Cream Cheese
  • Whipped Cream (Sugar-Free)

Cake Filling Choices:

  • Chocolate                                
  • Vanilla                         
  • Ricotta            
  • Raspberry
  • Blueberry
  • Apple
  • Pineapple
  • Strawberry
  • Lemon
  • Cherry

Specialty Cake Menu

  • Italian Fruit Cake: Sponge cake filled with fresh strawberries & peaches, topped off with whipped cream frosting.
  • Italian Rum Cake: Sponge cake filled with both chocolate & vanilla fillings, soaked with rum flavoring, topped with your choice of butter cream or whipped cream frosting & sliced almonds.
  • Chocolate Mousse Cake: Chocolate cake with a layer of chocolate filling & a layer of chocolate mousse filling, then topped off with chocolate mousse.
  • Cherry Nut Cake: A white cake with maraschino cherries & walnuts baked into the cake & topped with butter cream frosting.
  • Carrot Cake: Our carrot cake is NOT baked with any nuts in it. However, it is possible to order the carrot cake with nuts with at least 24 hours’ notice. The cake is filled & topped with our cream cheese frosting.
  • Tiramisu Cake: Sponge cake soaked in a coffee-brandy mixture, layered with tiramisu filling, sprinkled with cinnamon sugar over whipped cream & finished off with shaved milk chocolate.
  • Perugina Cake:  Pistachio flavored cake with ricotta filling, chocolate chips sprinkled inside, topped with ganache chocolate & whipped cream frosting.
  • Brown Derby Cake: Chocolate Cake filled with fresh strawberries & bananas, topped with whipped cream frosting & sprinkled with chocolate cake crumbs.
  • Black Forrest Cake: Chocolate Cake filled with cherry filling, topped with whipped cream frosting & sprinkled with chocolate cake crumbs.
  • Cannoli Cake: This cake can be done 2 ways. One is with white, chocolate, or marble cake & the other is with puff pastry. Both are filled with ricotta filling, sprinkled with chocolate chips in the center & then topped with your choice of butter cream or whipped cream frosting.
  • Raspberry Mousse Cake: White, chocolate, or marble cake filled with a layer of raspberry filling & a layer of raspberry mousse, topped with raspberry mousse.
  • Lemon Mousse Cake: White cake filled with a layer of lemon filling & a layer of lemon mousse, topped with lemon mousse.
  • Maple Walnut Cake:  Maple flavored cake baked with crushed walnuts in the cake mix, topped with a maple flavored butter cream frosting.
  • German Chocolate Cake: Chocolate cake filled with German chocolate filling, topped in both German chocolate & chocolate butter cream frosting.
  • Mocha Cake: White, chocolate, or marble cake, filled & topped with mocha butter cream frosting.
  • TV Bar Cake: Chocolate cake filled with butter cream frosting & topped with ganache chocolate.
  • Red Velvet Cake: A red chocolate-flavored cake, topped with cream cheese frosting & chocolate chips.
  • Cappuccino Cake: Sponge cake soaked with real cappuccino & filled with ricotta filling, sprinkled with chocolate chips in the center, then topped with whipped cream frosting & shaved milk chocolate. 
*If you are looking for a type of cake not listed here, feel free to ask if it is something we can or would be willing to make for you.

New York-Style Cheesecake

  • Mangiafico's Bakery is famous for their delicious New York-Style Cheesecake that can be purchased by the slice or as a whole cake (which is priced by the pound) while supplies last.
  • Because our cheesecakes are always made fresh, we encourage orders for a specific flavor cheesecake from the list below & the size of cheesecake be placed at least 1 day in advance to guarantee your order is ready upon pickup.
  • Our New York Style Cheesecake is gluten free.
  • To place an order for one of our famous cheesecakes, stop in the bakery or contact us by phone at (860) 793-9167.
Picture
A slice of Pistachio Cheesecake with a dollop of whipped cream.

Cheesecake Menu

  • Original New York-Style Cheesecake
The Following flavors are available with advanced notice.
  • Marble 
  • Pumpkin
  • Pistachio
  • Chocolate
  • Maple
  • Banana
  • Italian Ricotta Cheesecake: (Seasonal Offering By Order Only)